Bank Stock April Fools?
As we begin a new month and a new quarter financial stocks are flying. After the disastrous first quarter, the market seems to want to put the losses and bad news behind them and move forward. The question is should they?
Sometimes, as long term investors, we need to take a step back and look at what is happening instead fo what we hope is happening. This morning UBS AG (UBS) was out with its earnings report. It was so bad the chairman resigned in its wake. The bank reported a loss of over $12 billion. Total write-down's came to about $19billion. This brings the total losses for UBS to a staggering $40 billion so far in the mortgage and credit crisis. As a result of this Standard and Poors cut their credit rating to AA-. As a result of the downgrade the bank will be looking to raise as much as $15 billion of new capital. This will bring their capita ratios back up to over 10% when completed, well above the minimum of 4 set by the European Union. The bank also announced that it was continuing to cut its exposure to the US mortgage market. Subprime exposure has fallen from 27 billion to $15 billion and the portfolio of Alt-A mortgages shrank from $26 billion to $16 billion.
Also this morning Deutsche Bank said that it expected to announce at least $4 billion in asset write-down's when they release earnings on April 29. The losses are from the banks exposure to leveraged loans, Commercial real estate, and of course residential mortgage backed securities.
Influential banking industry analyst William Tanona of Goldman Sachs was out with reports this morning lowering his estimates on two bellwether financial stocks. He estimated that first quarter losses for Citigroup (c ) would be in 50% higher than his previous estimate. He expects the bank to have over $12 billion of new write downs from asset backed securities in the quarter and report a total loss of $1.55 a share, well above his previous estimate of a loss of just $.50 a share. He also cuts his full year profit estimate by 60% to $.50 a share. For Merrill Lynch (ML), Tanona estimated another $2.5 billion of write-down's and a quarterly loss $2.45. He also cuts his full year estimate to just $.70, down from $3.85, a cut of over 80%.
Major financial stocks are rallying this morning in expectations of better days ahead. The reality seems to be that the situation is still cloudy and best. Asset values continue to fall and earnings are expectations are drastically reduced. This appears to be one of those times where it is best to sit out the early rally to avoid the possibility of a permanent impairment of investment capital, sustaining huge losses that would take years to recover.



